Jay DeMarcus? Christmas Wish? A Colic-Free Baby!

"[For Christmas I want] a happy, healthy baby," the Rascal Flatts bassist told PEOPLE Wednesday at an N.Y.C. event announcing their partnership with JCPenney's ?Angel Giving Tree? program. "And if it's not too much to ask for Santa, preferably a baby without colic."

Ashley Tappin Ashley Tisdale Asia Argento Aubrey ODay